Week of September 21, 09 – Eureka! I Finally Had an Epiphany!

Filed under: , , by: Dan Randall

In several classes the terms “Instructional Theory,” “learning theory” and“ Instructional Design Theory” have been thrown around a lot and I think about half of us new-bees have just been thinking, “huh?” But I think I’m finally starting to understand the difference as well as why Andy is so into the idea of science vs. technology. To me, science and technology are so closely related that at first I couldn’t understand why anyone would bother to try and separate the two concepts. I guess most of the world probably feels that way. Even after reading/hearing about Andy’s opinions I’m still kind of apathetic towards the need to distinguish between the 2 fields. However, recognizing the distinction he draws makes understanding Instructional Theory and how it’s different from Instructional Design Theory a whole lot easier. As I understand it, Instructional Theory is a science oriented theory. It’s trying to describe what is happening or why something is working. Instructional Design Theory on the other hand is a technology oriented theory. It’s not so concerned with why something works but simply if it will probably work and how to use what we know will probably work to produce a desired outcome. It’s prescriptive in nature. Instructional Theorists are trying to understand why certain types of instruction work and Instructional Design theorists are trying to find out which types of instruction (methods) will work best to achieve a particular outcome (or work best in a particular situation). Both are closely connected but have different end goals in mind. Both generate new knowledge but they come at it from different angles. I feel like I’m been in a dark room labeled IPT but all of a sudden someone turned the lights on! Oh Happy Day!

1 comments:

On September 28, 2009 at 7:51 AM , Charles Graham said...

I think that the idea of a learning theory is to an instructional design theory as science is to technology.