Week of September 21, 09 – Eureka! I Finally Had an Epiphany!

Filed under: , , by: Dan Randall

In several classes the terms “Instructional Theory,” “learning theory” and“ Instructional Design Theory” have been thrown around a lot and I think about half of us new-bees have just been thinking, “huh?” But I think I’m finally starting to understand the difference as well as why Andy is so into the idea of science vs. technology. To me, science and technology are so closely related that at first I couldn’t understand why anyone would bother to try and separate the two concepts. I guess most of the world probably feels that way. Even after reading/hearing about Andy’s opinions I’m still kind of apathetic towards the need to distinguish between the 2 fields. However, recognizing the distinction he draws makes understanding Instructional Theory and how it’s different from Instructional Design Theory a whole lot easier. As I understand it, Instructional Theory is a science oriented theory. It’s trying to describe what is happening or why something is working. Instructional Design Theory on the other hand is a technology oriented theory. It’s not so concerned with why something works but simply if it will probably work and how to use what we know will probably work to produce a desired outcome. It’s prescriptive in nature. Instructional Theorists are trying to understand why certain types of instruction work and Instructional Design theorists are trying to find out which types of instruction (methods) will work best to achieve a particular outcome (or work best in a particular situation). Both are closely connected but have different end goals in mind. Both generate new knowledge but they come at it from different angles. I feel like I’m been in a dark room labeled IPT but all of a sudden someone turned the lights on! Oh Happy Day!

Week of September 14, 09 – It’s All Coming Together

Filed under: , , by: Dan Randall

Meta Cognition or the ability to think about one’s own thinking is an incredibly valuable tool in education. The more I have learned to do this in my own life (and I’m far form good at it), the more I have truly come to understand the subject matter at hand and not just memorize facts. I have been able to ask myself, “why would this be,” and “does this connect with something else I already know about (and can I draw an analogy between these 2 things), and “how does my own understanding of the world shape what I think about this new concept I’m learning?” Another valuable question I like to ask myself is “do I understand this concept in the same way that the person teaching me about it understands it or am I way off?” I would love to learn more about meta cognition and how I can effectively implement it in my own learning and in my instructional designs.

I also enjoyed reading about the differences between Behaviorism, Cognitivism and Constructivism. These 3 theories, along with lots of others, have been floating around in my head for a while now and this article has helped me nail down some of the main ideas and differences between them. The thing that really interested me is that it turns out I was beginning to grasp the relationships between these theories even before I read this article, I just didn’t know it! I feel somewhat relieved to know I actually am learning something in my classes instead of just feeling really confused all the time!

I agree with the idea that Behaviorism is good for learning simple things or things that require a lower level of cognitive processing. This fits well with what I know about behaviorism but also what I’ve experienced personally with higher level learning. As for constructivism, this article confirms what I had previously thought almost from the first time I learned about this theory. A constructivist approach would work well for higher level learning but students need a base of knowledge with which to work in order to participate in this higher order thinking about a subject. Before reading this article I thought you almost had to choose which theory you bought into, but in reality they all work with learning but just at different levels.

Outline for My Opinion of Learning

Filed under: by: Dan Randall

I. Processing- The more you process the more ingrained it becomes.

A. Types
1. Regurgitation (knowledge)
2. Analysis
3. Articulation
4. Social negotiation
5. Knowing – Doing – Becoming (?)

B. Different qualities of learning - Ex. Like having a box full of materials but the box doesn’t do you any good until you open the box and start using things. – like ingredients for a recipe.
1. Intro. Concept of Qualities – how usable is knowledge
2. Accessibility/retrieval

II. Motivation (enthusiasm)
A. Intrinsic vs Extrinsic

B. Affects on type of learning
C. Affects on quality of learning

Week of Sept. 7 – Constructivism

Filed under: by: Dan Randall

After reading about all these various educational philosophies and the adjoining psychological theories, I would have to say that I don’t agree with any of them. Each have an element or two that I endorse, but I don’t find myself drawn to any one of them, and certainly not enough to say “I think I’m a __________ (fill in the blank).” When we move away from theory and talk about actual instruction, I do embrace some aspects of Constructivism. However, I think that Constructivism should be used along with other instructional practices. I don’t think using a constructivist system to teach someone with little or no background in a field is a good idea. In order for constructivism to be most beneficial, I think the learner has to have a critical mass of information from which to start. Once this is established, a teaching mode utilizing constructivism would be useful. For example, telling a student who has little or no knowledge about Egypt to set their own study objectives for the subject would cause the student difficulty in trying to determine what they should study. It could also cause the student to miss important information which they would need later on in the class to be successful. Instead, I suggest teaching the student some important, beginning information about Egypt using more structured methods. Once this has been done, the student can be given more freedom to learn additional information about Egypt. The student could then delve deeper into a topic that interested them when they were learning the basic information. Having a little background in the subject allows the student to make a more informed choice about their learning goals which will lead to greater motivation and a better end result of their learning.
Another example that illustrates my idea of how to employ Constructivism comes from my high school “metals” shop class. All the first year students had to make the same project, a desk lap. This project included many aspects of metal working such as welding, drilling, grinding and forging. These skills form the basics in metal working and this project allowed the teacher to demonstrate each of these skills to the students as a class and then students could practice the skills on a meaningful project. This scaffold approach to Constructivism worked very well in this setting. The next year in the class, students designed their own projects and were able to learn additional skills needed to complete their project. Much of the scaffolding was removed in this 2nd year and students were able to learn in a more constructivist environment.
I guess my issue with Constructivism is that it is good for learning additional skills in a field and for exploring more in-depth information, but before these things can occur, more traditional instruction is needed to provide the students with a critical mass of knowledge. This mass of knowledge is needed to set learning goals and to try and determine how to learn these new skills that they will need in order to complete their goals.

PLE and RSS

Filed under: by: Dan Randall

What is a personal learning environment (PLE)?
A PLE is a place set up by the learner which allows them to take control of his or her own learning. PLE’s provide a place for a learner set their own goals about what they want to learn and connect with others who have similar interests and learning goals. PLEs also provide a place to store what you have learned allowing you to go back for future reference as well as add to that knowledge, in part, by connecting with sources for additional learning. While PLEs function very well on-line by allowing learners to connect to various websites, feeds and people, any environment which allows such actions to take place could serve as a PLE.
What elements make up a PLE?
PLE’s aren’t designed to be temporary but should be built on over time. It should allow you to collect resources such as articles, websites, etc, and be a place that allows you to connect to others in at least a limited basis.
How is a PLE different from a Learning Management System?
PLE’s are created by the learner for the learner’s needs and are usually broad in scope. LMS are created by an institution or organization designed to teach students a set of information. While both can foster on-line learning, PLE’s allow the student to be in the driver’s seat giving them control over what they learn while LMS’s control and direct the student’s learning.
What are some examples of PLEs?
Many things can serve as a PLE, a blog, wiki, personal website or even a social networking site in that it allows you to connect with others of similar interests. It’s not so much what you use but what it contains that makes a PLE a PLE.
What is an RSS feed?
A RSS (Rich Site Summary) feed is a connection to a website that has continually updating content, such as the News. RSS feeds allow a user to connect to this updating content (or at least a summary of it) without actually visiting the website.