I really enjoyed putting ethics into practice using the case studies. As we did so I kind of realized that your ethics usually have to flex a little in order to arrive at a solution. It seems like if your ethics can’t be too firm or you’ll never be happy or able to do anything. Maybe that’s one reason why ethics and morals are different: morals are unbending but ethics has to, of necessity, have some flexibility. I’ve known a few people who have zero flexibility in their career ethics and they are NEVER happy at their job. No matter what they are doing or where they are doing it, they don’t like the system or disagree with this or that and as a consequence doesn’t stay at a job more than 2 or 3 years. Perhaps it’s not that people like this are totally inflexible, maybe, like I said before, their level of conscience is too high for their own good. I guess it’s like anything else in life, you have to find the right balance that works for you but also that lets you function in society.
I really enjoyed watching everyone’s videos. I didn’t really have too many questions. One question I did have was about the person Danny interviewed. He mentioned he had a background in science and seminary and as a result he tended to work on those projects. Is that fairly normal in his setting or if it was just a coincidence?
The only other thing that really came to mind as I watched the videos was about the person Christijan shadowed. It mentioned it in the video but I would just like to know more details about how he got into a position as an Executive Producer and what my chances, personally, of being able to do that because it sounds like something I would be interested in doing.
For some reason I usually associate ethics with business or law. This is probably because those professions tend to have bad reputations for ethics or the lack thereof. Although I knew better, I always thought of ethics as the rules someone had to make so people without morals couldn’t do things that were too bad. But to hear about Russ Osguthorpe’s ideas about ethics was kind of a new take on the whole idea of ethics. I’d never thought of ethics in the sense of having a conscience about certain aspects of our career.
What I think I found most interesting was the differing opinions about what is ethical or rather, what level of conscience a person has. Take teachers for instance. I know many teachers that feel they aren’t doing a good job as a teacher and that they aren’t serving their students well if they aren’t putting in close to 50 or 60 hours a week. On the other hand, I felt little to no responsibility or conscience to put in anywhere close to that much over time. And anytime I mention this to any of these 60 hour a week teachers they seem to think I’m some kind of a bad person. It doesn’t offend me but often just makes me laugh. In a way, I kind of think that they are “bad” people (to use the term loosely) because they are obvious neglecting other things that they probably should be doing. So, I guess the big question is, why are is there such a disparity between what one person thinks is acceptable and what another thinks is acceptable? Does it mean one is lacking in morals? I don’t think so. Does it mean one misunderstands the importance of what they are doing? Perhaps, but not necessarily I don’t think. So, why the difference between people? Any idea?
I’ve never been a huge fan of forums. Perhaps it’s because they feel too disorganized to me. Or maybe it’s because the topic of most of the forums I’ve visited is usually about something that in my opinion is just a waste of time. So, when I heard we were going to learn about forums and how they can be used in teaching I was apprehensive to say the least. But after having used them for an educational purpose my opinions changed a little bit. I realized that they can be useful when done well. Educational forums usually have a meaningful topic and they tend to have more replies that are actually relevant to the topic. I also noticed that they seem to have fewer replies than other forums I’ve been on and so it’s easier to find what you are looking for.
Despite my negative feelings about forums I have recently begun using them to try and find solutions to programming problems I run into. This has been very helpful as I can get access to a group of experts that I would normally be unable to communicate with. I guess I’m starting to realize that forums are like pretty much everything else in the world, they can be used for good, productive purposes or for negative time-wasting purposes. Most of my previous experiences have been with the latter but if done right forums can be a great educational tool.
For a long time I’ve disliked video games and saw them as mostly negative and thought that they had very little value. However, a friend of mine has recently been trying to convince me otherwise. As I’ve been pondering whether or not video games have value I’ve heard a lot of people argue that they do. John Seely Brown spoke about the value he saw in video games and now in class the issue has come up again. I agree that it can be beneficial for those who are unsuccessful in many aspects of life as they can feel good about themselves because of the social interaction and success they find in video games. However, I think there is a better way for people to achieve these same goals.
So, do video games really have value? If you could make truly educational video games then I think they would be. I remember playing SimCity as a kid and a felt like I learned a lot. I learned about zoning and where to place zones in regards to each other. But, today I wonder if I really learned anything applicable today. Are the things I learned in the video game actually true in the real world? I honestly don’t know but I have a funny feeling that they aren’t. So, if the video game was truly educational then yes, it would have value, but I fear that what is actually happening is that video games give us a false sense of knowledge because we think we know something but in reality it is inaccurate.
I really enjoyed learning about how stories can play a part in teaching and learning. I’ve always loved telling stories and hearing other great stories. I think this is part of why I love movies so much: because they tend to tell a great story. My love of good stories is part of why I enjoy history as well.
I’ve always recognized the value of using stories to teach. If anyone doubts their usefulness just look at the scriptures, most of what’s in there are stories. What I found useful from the presentation on storytelling as an instructional tool was helping me to know when stories are effective, what stories have an ability to do, and how to organize stories to make them most effective. Specifically, some things that stood out to me were:
• Simplicity, unexpectedness, concreteness, credibility, emotionally appealing, and stories helps make info stick.
• If you can learn how to tell a story well and relate to human interact, you will be successful in anything in life. Watch human behavior and create your own stories from your life that relate to behavior and use them to teach others.
• Some things aren’t as efficiently taught with a story. For example, doing long division.
• Narrative is really good at teaching morals and principles, etc, but not as good at teaching procedures, etc.
• It’s important to know your audience when using stories for teaching.
• Science is about making up stories and seeing if it really applies to life. Science is basically trying to tell a story.
• Stories are a powerful way to teach, but they can also teach things that you didn’t intend to teach.
• “A lie can travel half way around the world before truth even gets its boots on.”
I was amazed to learn how many journals are out there that are connected with our field. I never stopped to really think about it until I did this assignment. I figured there were maybe 4 or 5, but no more than 10 journals that everyone published to, but clearly I was mistaken. I liked being able to hear a little about so many different journals so I could get an idea of what journals might be of interest to me. Besides the Quarterly Review for Distance Learning (the one I did), the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education (what a mouth full!) and the Comparative Education Review all caught my interest. These caught my eye partly because they were international publications and anything international tends to draw me in, but there is another reason these journals are of interest to me. I am interested in many aspects of distance learning and it sounds like these journals would be a good source to use as I learn more about distance learning. One thing I would like to learn more about specifically in regards to distance education is the social effect such a learning environment would have on students. I can’t prove it, but I just feel like there is something major that is lost when in-person human interaction is completely replaced. I think distance learning is a great option for those who cannot attend a class but to completely replace a regular class with online learning I think would be a mistake. Using online tools to supplement learning would be great and maybe even meeting a little less often, but completely replacing in person learning, no, I think that is bad. That is why I am interested in knowing more about blended learning as I think (from what I know) that is a good mix between online and in-person learning as you have the benefits of both learning environments.
It was interesting to learn a little more about wikis and their use in education. I’ve heard people talk about the fact that wikis can be a great tool to encourage collaboration but I’ve never heard any real specifics about how to use them for this purpose. It seems like they could be utilized in many different ways to encourage collaboration and to enhance the learning environment. I looked around online trying to find more applications of wikis in education. I found examples of people using wikis in place of a class website. Other teachers employed wikis in group projects so that students in their class could work together without actually being in the same room, something very helpful for middle school students who may have internet access but can’t as easily meet with their peers to work on a project. I imagine this could work to connect several sections of a class a teacher might have allowing them to all collaborate on a large project. I wish I’d thought about doing that when I was teaching high school and had 4 different classes all studying the same topic! I saw another wiki that a teacher used to help teach Spanish. Finally, I saw a wiki that teachers in a department for a particular school were using to collaborate and share lesson ideas. Teachers could even post lesson materials on a wiki for other teachers to use. I am sure that there are many more ways to utilize wikis, probably lots of ways most people having even thought of yet! Does anyone have any other good ideas about how to use wikis in education, especially collaborative learning? If so, please post a comment telling about your ideas.
I was pretty bummed that I missed the Media vs. Method debate. I read through the judges’ findings and I have to agree with their decision based on the things I read and heard about. I felt that the whole idea of trying to separate media from method was kind of silly. The two are so connected that you can’t really look at one without the other. I think something that could be researched (and it probably already has been researched to at least some extent) is what method works best with what media. I think everyone agreed that certain methods worked better with certain kinds of media and it would be interesting to find out which ones work best with each other. However, there could be more involved in the interplay of media and method, such as content, so it might not be as easy to research as it sounds. Another interesting, related question that came to mind during all this was when you are producing an instructional design and you have constraints such as time, money, etc., what do you spend more resources on, improving the method or the media? Or can you even focus on one more than the other? I guess the question I’m really trying to ask is, how do the results of the media vs. method debate apply to the practice of instructional design, especially when there are constraints involved? Anyone have any thoughts?
Week of October 12 –What I want to do When I Grow up
It was interesting to see what jobs are available and the requirements I would need to have in order to go into a particular area. I’ve been thinking about the possibility of going into Human Performance because it sounds like there would be quite a bit of variety in what I did. However, after the presentation this week I have to admit I am not as interested in it anymore because it sounds like I would have to do a lot more schooling to learn HR laws and other things like that. I am still interested in working at a teaching and learning center at a university and even one day being the head of such a center. But, if I understood the presentation correctly, it sounds like I’d probably have to be a professor first if I wanted to get that position and I’m still not real sure I want to be a professor. I really enjoy teaching at the university level but I don’t care too much for research. So, as things stand right now, I think I am still most interested in just being an instructional designer either in an HR department or working for a company that specializes in instructional design (the latter would be my preference). If I went with this last opinion, I would want to eventually work my way to the top of the company and I’m not sure if I could do that with just a master’s degree or if I would need to get my PhD. So, I guess that’s what I need to figure out in the next year.
One thing I’ve learned from the church and the gospel in general is the need to have repetition in learning. So many scriptures repeat the same principles or even use the same analogies again and again. Modern prophets today often speak in General Conference on the same topics multiple times. Something I learned in various education classes is the advantage of using multiple forms of media to teach. I have started to see this more and more in General Conference. Speakers use short videos, pictures, and often refer to the hymns sung in a session to help teach various principles. This stood out to me especially during Bro. Osguthorpe’s talk. Even in Sunday School the church is using more videos to help teach gospel lessons. One thing I’ve learned from both sides is the importance of example. Church leaders are constantly emphasizing the importance of setting a good example both for our children and for those around us. In secular learning, this is similar to modeling a behavior or a procedure. So much of the gospel is about learning that I am sure that there are more connections between what I’ve learned in a gospel setting and what I’ve learned in a secular setting than what I have made mention of here. To me, the important thing to remember is that Jesus is the master teacher which is why I always thought it was so fitting when people referred to him as rabbi.
After reading all these articles I think I have a better understanding of how a Human Resources department might operate. I always thought of HR as the place where people are hired or fired, endless paper work is done (for the government, insurance, etc), where training happened and where work related problems were fixed. Within that domain, I always saw myself as the “training guy,” but now I realize how Instructional Technology and Human Performance Technology fit within HR and how they interact. The instructional Designer would handle the training (I like that title a lot better than “training guy”) but the Human Performance Technologist spends his time trying to understand the true cause of a problem and what should be done in order to resolve it. If it is simply a training matter, the instructional designer would step in and create some training. If it was something more than that, the Human Performance Tech would try and find the solution. Before this class, I didn’t know there was such a thing as a Human Performance Tech and the things he does I always just thought a human resources person would do along with many other HR tasks. Now I realize there’s actually a specialization within HR that deals with those performance type of problems.
Week of September 21, 09 – Eureka! I Finally Had an Epiphany!
In several classes the terms “Instructional Theory,” “learning theory” and“ Instructional Design Theory” have been thrown around a lot and I think about half of us new-bees have just been thinking, “huh?” But I think I’m finally starting to understand the difference as well as why Andy is so into the idea of science vs. technology. To me, science and technology are so closely related that at first I couldn’t understand why anyone would bother to try and separate the two concepts. I guess most of the world probably feels that way. Even after reading/hearing about Andy’s opinions I’m still kind of apathetic towards the need to distinguish between the 2 fields. However, recognizing the distinction he draws makes understanding Instructional Theory and how it’s different from Instructional Design Theory a whole lot easier. As I understand it, Instructional Theory is a science oriented theory. It’s trying to describe what is happening or why something is working. Instructional Design Theory on the other hand is a technology oriented theory. It’s not so concerned with why something works but simply if it will probably work and how to use what we know will probably work to produce a desired outcome. It’s prescriptive in nature. Instructional Theorists are trying to understand why certain types of instruction work and Instructional Design theorists are trying to find out which types of instruction (methods) will work best to achieve a particular outcome (or work best in a particular situation). Both are closely connected but have different end goals in mind. Both generate new knowledge but they come at it from different angles. I feel like I’m been in a dark room labeled IPT but all of a sudden someone turned the lights on! Oh Happy Day!
Week of September 14, 09 – It’s All Coming Together
Meta Cognition or the ability to think about one’s own thinking is an incredibly valuable tool in education. The more I have learned to do this in my own life (and I’m far form good at it), the more I have truly come to understand the subject matter at hand and not just memorize facts. I have been able to ask myself, “why would this be,” and “does this connect with something else I already know about (and can I draw an analogy between these 2 things), and “how does my own understanding of the world shape what I think about this new concept I’m learning?” Another valuable question I like to ask myself is “do I understand this concept in the same way that the person teaching me about it understands it or am I way off?” I would love to learn more about meta cognition and how I can effectively implement it in my own learning and in my instructional designs.
I also enjoyed reading about the differences between Behaviorism, Cognitivism and Constructivism. These 3 theories, along with lots of others, have been floating around in my head for a while now and this article has helped me nail down some of the main ideas and differences between them. The thing that really interested me is that it turns out I was beginning to grasp the relationships between these theories even before I read this article, I just didn’t know it! I feel somewhat relieved to know I actually am learning something in my classes instead of just feeling really confused all the time!
I agree with the idea that Behaviorism is good for learning simple things or things that require a lower level of cognitive processing. This fits well with what I know about behaviorism but also what I’ve experienced personally with higher level learning. As for constructivism, this article confirms what I had previously thought almost from the first time I learned about this theory. A constructivist approach would work well for higher level learning but students need a base of knowledge with which to work in order to participate in this higher order thinking about a subject. Before reading this article I thought you almost had to choose which theory you bought into, but in reality they all work with learning but just at different levels.
I. Processing- The more you process the more ingrained it becomes.
A. Types
1. Regurgitation (knowledge)
2. Analysis
3. Articulation
4. Social negotiation
5. Knowing – Doing – Becoming (?)
B. Different qualities of learning - Ex. Like having a box full of materials but the box doesn’t do you any good until you open the box and start using things. – like ingredients for a recipe.
1. Intro. Concept of Qualities – how usable is knowledge
2. Accessibility/retrieval
II. Motivation (enthusiasm)
A. Intrinsic vs Extrinsic
B. Affects on type of learning
C. Affects on quality of learning
After reading about all these various educational philosophies and the adjoining psychological theories, I would have to say that I don’t agree with any of them. Each have an element or two that I endorse, but I don’t find myself drawn to any one of them, and certainly not enough to say “I think I’m a __________ (fill in the blank).” When we move away from theory and talk about actual instruction, I do embrace some aspects of Constructivism. However, I think that Constructivism should be used along with other instructional practices. I don’t think using a constructivist system to teach someone with little or no background in a field is a good idea. In order for constructivism to be most beneficial, I think the learner has to have a critical mass of information from which to start. Once this is established, a teaching mode utilizing constructivism would be useful. For example, telling a student who has little or no knowledge about Egypt to set their own study objectives for the subject would cause the student difficulty in trying to determine what they should study. It could also cause the student to miss important information which they would need later on in the class to be successful. Instead, I suggest teaching the student some important, beginning information about Egypt using more structured methods. Once this has been done, the student can be given more freedom to learn additional information about Egypt. The student could then delve deeper into a topic that interested them when they were learning the basic information. Having a little background in the subject allows the student to make a more informed choice about their learning goals which will lead to greater motivation and a better end result of their learning.
Another example that illustrates my idea of how to employ Constructivism comes from my high school “metals” shop class. All the first year students had to make the same project, a desk lap. This project included many aspects of metal working such as welding, drilling, grinding and forging. These skills form the basics in metal working and this project allowed the teacher to demonstrate each of these skills to the students as a class and then students could practice the skills on a meaningful project. This scaffold approach to Constructivism worked very well in this setting. The next year in the class, students designed their own projects and were able to learn additional skills needed to complete their project. Much of the scaffolding was removed in this 2nd year and students were able to learn in a more constructivist environment.
I guess my issue with Constructivism is that it is good for learning additional skills in a field and for exploring more in-depth information, but before these things can occur, more traditional instruction is needed to provide the students with a critical mass of knowledge. This mass of knowledge is needed to set learning goals and to try and determine how to learn these new skills that they will need in order to complete their goals.
What is a personal learning environment (PLE)?
A PLE is a place set up by the learner which allows them to take control of his or her own learning. PLE’s provide a place for a learner set their own goals about what they want to learn and connect with others who have similar interests and learning goals. PLEs also provide a place to store what you have learned allowing you to go back for future reference as well as add to that knowledge, in part, by connecting with sources for additional learning. While PLEs function very well on-line by allowing learners to connect to various websites, feeds and people, any environment which allows such actions to take place could serve as a PLE.
What elements make up a PLE?
PLE’s aren’t designed to be temporary but should be built on over time. It should allow you to collect resources such as articles, websites, etc, and be a place that allows you to connect to others in at least a limited basis.
How is a PLE different from a Learning Management System?
PLE’s are created by the learner for the learner’s needs and are usually broad in scope. LMS are created by an institution or organization designed to teach students a set of information. While both can foster on-line learning, PLE’s allow the student to be in the driver’s seat giving them control over what they learn while LMS’s control and direct the student’s learning.
What are some examples of PLEs?
Many things can serve as a PLE, a blog, wiki, personal website or even a social networking site in that it allows you to connect with others of similar interests. It’s not so much what you use but what it contains that makes a PLE a PLE.
What is an RSS feed?
A RSS (Rich Site Summary) feed is a connection to a website that has continually updating content, such as the News. RSS feeds allow a user to connect to this updating content (or at least a summary of it) without actually visiting the website.

